CSci 4511w: Writing Assignments
|
Always include the number of the writing you are submitting,
your name and ID on any material you submit for grading.
Unless otherwise instructed you are free to format your writings
as you want. Please use single spacing and a font size of 11 or
bigger. Typically a page has 25-30 lines.
Each writing assignment can be resubmitted for regrading, unless otherwise
specified. You are allowed one resubmission per writing, which has to be
within two weeks from when you received the original writing back. When
you submit for regrading, please submit also the original writing.
Writing 5 - due Tuesday April 20
This is the next step for your project report. The major part you need
to include in it is a 2-3 pages literature review of relevant publications
related to your project. The review should include 8-10 relevant
references with bibliographic citations. For each of the references you
should write a sentence or two describing briefly what that reference
talks about and the approach taken in it, and comparing it to your own
work. Your work can follow the same lines or can take a different approach.
What is important is to show some mastery of the relevant work done by
others on the subject of your project. If there are multiple team members
please specify the contribution of each member.
There will not be time to resubmit this writing, but you will
receive this writing back within a week, so you'll be able to use the
feedback to improve your final paper.
You are welcome to include in this writing any additional material that
you will have in your final project. This is the last chance to have it
reviewed before the final submission.
Writing 4 - due Thursday March 25
This is a short proposal for your project and a report on
any initial work you have done.
It should be two to three pages long and should include:
- team members. If there are multiple students doing the same
project you can submit a single paper,
indicating which parts
each person wrote. A paper with more than one author is expected
to be longer to reflect the larger effort.
- a brief description of the problem you intend to address and
why it is interesting,
- the approach you will take to solve it,
- the software you'll need to write or to use,
- how you will evaluate your solution,
- a plan for the remaining work and related timeframe,
- the bibliographic references of at least 2-3 relevant papers.
In this writing you need to include a picture, a table, and an equation.
- For pictures, look at
http://www.andy-roberts.net/misc/latex/latextutorial5.html, which
explains how to use the package graphicx. It is not the only package
for graphics, but it is widely used and very simple. If you use a latex
implementation under Windows that generates directly the pdf file (under
linux it is called pdflatex) you can include figures in different
formats, including .png and .jpeg. Please include a
caption and figure number for your figure. Look at
http://www.andy-roberts.net/misc/latex/latextutorial6.html for how
to do it.
For example,
\documentclass[11pt]{article}
\usepackage{graphicx}
....
\begin{document}
...
\begin{figure}[ht]
\includegraphics[width=4in]{mypicture.eps}
\caption{\label{mypict} This is a sample picture}
\end{figure}
- For tables, I suggest you look at
http://www.andy-roberts.net/misc/latex/latextutorial4.html.
You could use a table for showing the
timeframe for the remaining work or for anything else you like.
Something like this
\begin{tabular}{l | l}
Topic & Expected completion date \\ \hline
Read related work & April 6 \\
Install software package XYZ & March 23\\
... & ... \\ \hline
\end{tabular}
- Finally you need to include at least one math equation. It can be
a very simple equation, either embedded in the text or printed on a separate
line with or withut an equation number.
Look at
http://www.andy-roberts.net/misc/latex/latextutorial9.html
for examples. To include the equation in the text use $ ... $,
to produce it on a separate line without an equation number use
\[...\],
to produce it on a separate line with an equation number use
\begin{equation} ...\end{equation}. For instance, $x^2$ will produce
x2 in the text, \[ x^2 \] will produce x2 on a
separate line with no equation number. If you need to use special
symbols (greek letters, math symbols, arrows, etc) you can find a
list at
http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Wiki/index.php/LaTeX:Symbols
Grading criteria:
(1) 35% for the contents,
(2) 25% for the writing style,
(3) 10% for using Latex and bibtex,
(4) 10% for including in the proposal at least one figure,
(5) 10% for including in the proposal at least one table,
(5) 10% for including in the proposal at least one equation.
Writing 3 - due Tuesday February 23
Resubmission due by Thursday March 25
For this writing you will start reporting ideas on research that will
lead you to your class project. When starting research in any subject,
the first step is to do a quick literature search to get acquainted
with the basic issues in the subject. This is not a full literature
review (you will do it for a later writing assignment), it is just
the first step in thinking about problems and questions you might
want to address in your project.
- write approximatively 1 page describing the topic (or topics)
you are interested in, why they are interesting, and what you think
you will do. Provide a few sentences on who has studied them with
relevant citations. You do not need to make any commitment at this
point to what you will do for your project.
-
include at least 5 bibliographical references of different types
(journal article, book, conference paper, technical report or thesis,
and url). Format the references using bibtex. If your
latex implementation does not include url as a recognized field,
use note for the field, followed by whatever you want to include.
You can look at
http://www.andy-roberts.net/misc/latex/latextutorial3.html for
details on how to do bibliographies in Latex.
Grading criteria: (1) 1/4 for the contents of the writing,
(2) 1/4 for the writing style,
(3) 1/4 for using Latex for the writing and using bibtex to generate
the bibliography, and
(4) 1/4 for including at least 5 bibliographical references of different types
(journal article, book, conference paper, technical report or thesis, and url).
Writing 2 - due Tuesday February 9
Resubmission due by Thursday March 11
Question 1.2 from the 3rd edition of the textbook, which says
"Read Turing's original paper on AI (Turing, 1950). In the paper, he
discusses several objections to his proposed enterprise and his test for
intelligence. Which objections still carry weight? Are his refutations
valid? Can you think of new objections arising from developments since he
wrote the paper? In the paper, he predicts that, by the year 2000, a
computer will have a 30% chance of passing a five minute Turing Test with
an unskilled interrogator. What chance do you think a computer would have
today? In another 50 years?"
- read the paper
A. M. Turing,
Computing machinery and intelligence.
Mind, 59, pp. 433-460, 1950.
- to do good writing you need to get informed on more recent
developments on Turing Test. For instance, you can look at the
Loebner Prize
and then read about some criticism of the prize in
Lessons from a Restricted Turing Test by
Stuart M. Shieber, Harvard University, April 15, 1993.
In Response
by Hugh Loebner.
This is an example, by no means these are the only additional sources
of information.
- write 2 pages answering the questions listed above and using any of
the additional information you have found to support your arguments.
Do not forget to include references to the work you use.
- You have to use Latex. Look for instructions on
Latex in the Material on Writing.
Grading criteria: 1/4 for answering the questions, 1/4 for using
additional cited information to support your answers, 1/4 for writing style,
and 1/4 for using Latex.
Please look at the forum for discussion on latex. Two
important things I said there: (1) for this time only you can write the
references any way you like, without having to use bibtex; (2) for this
time only you are allowed to submit the .dvi file using submit
if you cannot generate the .pdf file from the .dvi file.
I hope this will reduce the level of anxieties this assignment
has created.
Writing 1 - due Tuesday January 26
- Select and read one of the papers from
The Singularity Issue of IEEE Spectrum.
The papers are all short and written for a general educated public.
The issue is accessible from campus. If you access it from outside
campus, you will have to authenticate with your X.500 account.
- Write a 1-page summary and review of the paper you have read.
Your summary should be 8-10 lines long and say succintly what is in the paper.
Not your opinion about the paper but a summary of the paper itself.
The idea is that a reader who has not read the paper should be able
to find out what the paper is about. The summary should be followed
by your comments and opinion about the paper. You are free to express
your own opinion, but as much as possible you should base your opinions
on science. For instance, you can bring an example from another
paper or book that contraddicts what the author says.
- Bring your writing to class on Tuesday. We will divide in groups,
each student will read the writing of another student, then each
group will have a short discussion on the papers read.
- At the end of the class turn in your writing to get credit.
Grading criteria: 1/3 for the summary, 1/3 for the comments, and 1/3 for
writing style.
Copyright: © 2010 by the Regents of the University
of Minnesota
Department of Computer Science and
Engineering. All rights reserved.
Comments to: Maria Gini
Changes and corrections are in red.